In October 2026, Scottsdale's median sold price was $964,500, according to the Scottsdale REALTORS October market report. That is $79,500 above October 2025. In the same month, metro Phoenix moved further into buyer's territory. Scottsdale homes did not gain almost 9% in a year. The citywide median rose because a different set of homes closed. The real price gains over the past year are in a handful of ZIP codes, including McCormick Ranch's 85258, and several other Scottsdale ZIPs barely moved.
If you're choosing between parts of Scottsdale, the ZIP code tells you more than the city median.
The October median next to the rest of the report
The rest of the report looks like a cooling market. Scottsdale closed 454 sales in October 2026, against 529 in October 2025, about 14% fewer. Active listings at the end of October totaled 2,711, which is 51 more than a year earlier. Supply reached 5.45 months of inventory, up from 5.1 in October 2025. The median home spent 50 days in the RPR data last month, up from 46 the year before. Sellers got 96.8% of list price, about the same as October 2025.
Metro Phoenix looks the same, only more so. AZ Big Media reported 27,427 active listings across the metro in October, up 6.8% from a year earlier. Listings under contract fell 13.5% and closed sales dropped 9.8%. As of November 14, The Cromford Report had its Market Index at 63.5, a buyer's market reading that is 17 points lower than three months earlier.
Two other figures in the Scottsdale report show the gap. The median price per square foot on October sales was $435, compared with $421 in October 2025, an increase of about 3%. RPR's model put Scottsdale's median estimated property value at $864,420, up 0.3% over the 12 months through October. So the median sale rose almost 9%, price per square foot rose about 3%, and the estimated value of a typical Scottsdale home was nearly flat. A gap that wide usually means the October sales leaned toward larger or pricier homes, not that every home gained.
That is why the next step is to look at each part of the city separately. The RPR report counts houses, condos and townhomes together, and one month of sales across the whole city can tilt toward one area or one price range.
Where prices rose in the past year
Cromford publishes a ZIP code ranking based on a steadier measure: the median price per square foot of single-family detached homes over the 12 months ending November 13, 2026, compared with the 12 months before that. For Scottsdale and the ZIPs next to it, the numbers below come from Cromford's ZIP code ranking.
| ZIP | Closings, past 12 months | Median $/sq ft now | One year earlier | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 85260 | 384 | $444.07 | $420.28 | +5.7% |
| 85258 | 393 | $534.09 | $506.00 | +5.6% |
| 85255 | 940 | $529.19 | $506.54 | +4.5% |
| 85262 | 506 | $469.34 | $452.74 | +3.7% |
| 85259 | 353 | $440.25 | $426.96 | +3.1% |
| 85250 | 155 | $454.13 | $441.92 | +2.8% |
| 85254 | 732 | $432.71 | $427.08 | +1.3% |
| 85266 | 349 | $467.01 | $462.63 | +0.9% |
| 85257 | 327 | $388.50 | $386.92 | +0.4% |
| 85251 | 260 | $467.63 | $469.61 | -0.4% |
Scottsdale as a whole gained 2.8% on this measure over the same period, across 4,399 detached closings. No Scottsdale ZIP fell much. The spread still matters, because it changed the order of the city's ZIP codes. A year ago, 85258 and 85255 were essentially tied at about $506 a square foot. Now 85258 is slightly ahead. Last year 85260 trailed 85254. Now it is about $11 a square foot higher. And 85251 was the most expensive of these ZIPs a year ago at $469.61. Now 85262 has caught up to it and 85258 and 85255 are well ahead.
Next door, prices moved in very different directions. Paradise Valley's 85253 rose 10.4% to $880.99 a square foot. Carefree's 85377 fell 6.4% and Fountain Hills' 85268 fell 2.3%. Cave Creek's 85331 rose 0.6%. We broke down how much one town's numbers can hide in our Fountain Hills price analysis, and Scottsdale works the same way on a bigger scale.
Where the gains landed
85258 is home to McCormick Ranch, which its property owners' association calls Scottsdale's premier master-planned community. The association holds its board and committee meetings at its board room at 9248 N. 94th St., in that ZIP. Over the past year, detached homes in 85258 gained 5.6% per square foot, about twice the citywide figure.
85255 had the most activity, with 940 detached closings in 12 months. That is more than twice as many as most other Scottsdale ZIPs, and price per square foot still rose 4.5%. With that many sales behind it, the gain is hard to explain away as a few big closings. Along Scottsdale Road, the city council voted 7–0 on June 9, 2026 to approve an amendment to the One Scottsdale plan at 19601 N. Scottsdale Road. The Arizona Republic has described One Scottsdale as a 100-acre mixed-use project with luxury condos and a hotel.
85266 stands out next to 85262. Its detached homes sell for about the same per square foot as 85262, but they gained only 0.9% over the year. Buyers comparing these two ZIPs may find the two ZIPs have similar price levels but have moved at different speeds.
The flattest ZIPs, and the housing planned around Old Town
The two ZIPs at the bottom of the table, 85257 and 85251, were essentially flat over the past 12 months. Old Town is the city's urban center, and buyers who want to live near it are choosing among more kinds of housing. The city's Old Town Character Area plan defines Old Town by Scottsdale Road, the Arizona Canal, Indian School Road and Chaparral Road.
Buyers looking around Old Town will find more apartments and condos planned or under way. On November 12, 2026, the Arizona Republic reported that HonorHealth has proposed two nine-story buildings at Second Street and Drinkwater Boulevard, with about 460 hotel rooms and residential units, next to its medical campus. At 4605 N. Scottsdale Road, Hazel & Azure is a two-building luxury apartment project. Hazel faces Fashion Square and Azure sits along the Arizona Canal, according to the Republic's March 2026 report. Scottsdale Progress has reported on the 54-unit Magnolia Waterside, which is approved, and on a proposed 232-unit project at 5th and Goldwater.
This new housing does not explain the flat detached prices on its own. It does mean that someone who wants to be near Old Town will have more types of homes to compare before choosing a detached house.
Using the ZIP numbers when you compare homes
Across Scottsdale, the October report shows a market where buyers have time. There are more than five months of supply, homes are taking longer to sell, and sellers are getting a little under 97% of their asking price. The ZIP figures show how that plays out by area. In 85258, 85260 and 85255, price per square foot kept rising while the metro cooled, so sellers there have recent comparable sales behind their asking prices. In 85251, 85257 and 85266, the past year's sales have stayed near last year's levels, so an asking price above those levels has less recent support. If a listing is priced well above its ZIP's 12-month median, the burden is on that home to show why.
The ZIP numbers also explain the citywide median. In a month when more of the sales came from 85258 or 85255 and fewer from 85257, the citywide median would rise even if no individual home's value changed. That is consistent with October: the citywide median jumped while estimated values barely moved. When you compare a listing to a price, use its ZIP's numbers, and ideally its subdivision's.
If you're comparing McCormick Ranch with a home near Old Town, or 85266 with 85262, NEWHAUS Real Estate Team will pull the recent closed sales for each subdivision so you can see how each area has been pricing. If you own a home in one of these ZIPs, request your complimentary home valuation and we'll show you where your home sits against its ZIP's figures.